Capacity Is Crucial
Psychological studies, international human rights law and the everyday realities of Australia’s legal expectations of children all support the idea of empowering children whenever they are ready to be empowered, and without reference to any particular birthday.
In Australia, children are given legal rights and responsibilities in accordance with their capacity to comprehend those rights and responsibilities. This legal principle of assessing capacity may provide the basis for avoiding confrontation and transitioning high school students slowly into adulthood via supported decision making.
Article 12(1) of The United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child 1989 (which Australia has signed) provides:
‘the child who is capable of forming his or her own views’ should have the right to express those views, and that the views should be ‘given due weight in accordance with the age and maturity of the child’.
While historically the law has generally assumed that children do not have the capacity to participate in legal processes on their own behalf, more recent psychological studies have provided a greater understanding of children’s cognitive abilities and prompted a re-evaluation of rules regarding children’s capacity.
In Australian Courts
legal capacity cuts both ways for kids. A child’s particular interest in, or ability to comprehend legal rights and responsibilities will determine both the degree to which they are given rights and how accountable they will be held to be for the decisions they make. An assessment of capacity will determine whether a child is criminally responsible for their actions as well as whether a parent is responsible for paying
child support for their offspring beyond their 18th birthday.
For schools, teachers and parents these legal realities, human rights principles and supporting psychological science may hold the key to effectively managing the transition of dependent children into independent adults.
In a practical sense preparing students and parents for the inevitable legal coming of age well before second semester in Year 12 should assist in avoiding dramatic rebellion just before final exams.